Bookmarks

Yahoo Gmail Google Facebook Delicious Twitter Reddit Stumpleupon Myspace Digg

Search queries

ksh xxx, wwwwxxxw CD, wwwwxxxw CD, xx xmo, xxxmo,cvery, xxxcomwww xxxcomwww xxxcom, xxxxxnb, xxxxxnb, xxxxxnb, xxxxxnb

Links

XODOX
Impressum

#1: makeconnection: Invalid argument

Posted on 2007-10-06 22:58:32 by Captain Bob

What's wrong here????

*****First an outbound connection via ESMTP*****

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
<XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Connecting to smtp10.sympatico.ca. via esm
tp...

*****Is it that sympatico.ca doesn't understand ESMTP??*****

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.78]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.80]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.82]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.86]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.62]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.64]) failed: Invalid
argument

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.66]) failed: Invalid
argument

*****Finally SMTP is tried??*****

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: SMTP
outgoing connect on my.mail.server.com

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
<XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Closing connection to quoll.law.uiuc.edu.

*****Closing connection to a different server???*****
*****Now, there was a Cc: to an address at uiuc.edu*****
*****And I assume that is the connection which is*****
*****being referred to here*****

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
<XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Sent (ok: Message 402292785 accepted)

Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
to=<XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>, delay=00:00:24, xdelay=00:00:00,
mailer=esmtp, pri=23

*****BUT, the "mailer" ended up being ESMTP??*****

*******************

So after much effort, the email is delivered!

What I don't understand is the persistent makeconnection failures to
different MX's

Perhaps someone can shed some light on this??

Bob


--
/"\
\ / ASCII Ribbon Campaign - Motor Vessel Tamara B
X against HTML email & vCards - http://www.tamara-b.org
/ \ Tania Our Cat http://www.tamara-b.org/t1.jpg
.. . http://www.tamara-b.org/t2.jpg

Report this message

#2: Re: makeconnection: Invalid argument

Posted on 2007-10-07 18:32:28 by Bill Cole

In article <20071006165832.1d675667@tania.servebbs.org>,
Bob <bob@tania.servebbs.org> wrote:

> What's wrong here????

I'm not sure, but I can rule out a theory...


> *****First an outbound connection via ESMTP*****
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
> <XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Connecting to smtp10.sympatico.ca. via esm
> tp...
>
> *****Is it that sympatico.ca doesn't understand ESMTP??*****

No.

>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.78]) failed: Invalid
> argument

'makeconnection' just sets up the TCP connection. It can't fail on the
SMTP/ESMTP distinction, because that distinction is purely in the
application layer, not the transport layer.

Looking briefly at the relevant code in sendmail/daemon.c is only
slightly illuminating and requires more digging into other areas than I
feel like doing on a Sunday morning to fully understand, but the fact
that it is coming out of a default case and is only logged at LogLevel's
above 13 implies that this is not a serious problem.



> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.80]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.82]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.86]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.62]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.64]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> makeconnection (smtp10.sympatico.ca. [206.47.199.66]) failed: Invalid
> argument
>
> *****Finally SMTP is tried??*****
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: SMTP
> outgoing connect on my.mail.server.com

Note that SMTP and ESMTP are identical at the connection level. ESMTP is
just a name for a collection of optional application-level extensions to
the original SMTP definition that the 'esmtp' mailer will probe for.


> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
> <XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Closing connection to quoll.law.uiuc.edu.
>
> *****Closing connection to a different server???*****
> *****Now, there was a Cc: to an address at uiuc.edu*****
> *****And I assume that is the connection which is*****
> *****being referred to here*****
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871: --- 050
> <XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>... Sent (ok: Message 402292785 accepted)
>
> Oct 6 06:50:55 sm-mta[2770]: l96AoVn8014871:
> to=<XXXXX@nb.sympatico.ca>, delay=00:00:24, xdelay=00:00:00,
> mailer=esmtp, pri=23
>
> *****BUT, the "mailer" ended up being ESMTP??*****

These log lines do look strange. Have you done anything more than
linebreaking them and replacing the recipient local part? Are you
sharing *ALL* lines with that queue ID or expecting us to guess at what
is missing?

I would expect 'relay=<host>' and 'dsn=<status>' fields in any line
recording disposition of a particular address, i.e. with 'to=',
'delay=', and 'xdelay=' fields. Has your sendmail been modified or are
you hiding critical information?

> So after much effort, the email is delivered!
>
> What I don't understand is the persistent makeconnection failures to
> different MX's

Not different MX's, different addresses belonging to the same hostname,
which is pointed to by a single MX record. For whatever "Invalid
argument" means at that point, the code seems to imply that it is not a
condition that Sendmail deems specifically important, since it logs it
only at an unusually verbose LogLevel setting.

> Perhaps someone can shed some light on this??

Not much, but maybe I've narrowed your search for an answer.

--
Now where did I hide that website...

Report this message

#3: Re: makeconnection: Invalid argument

Posted on 2007-10-08 17:50:24 by Captain Bob

On Sun, 07 Oct 2007 12:32:28 -0400 Bill Cole Said In Re:
makeconnection: Invalid argument These words of wisdome:

| > Perhaps someone can shed some light on this??
|
| Not much, but maybe I've narrowed your search for an answer.
|

Yes you have. I have found a correlation between these errors and my
firewall logs, seems IPF is rejecting some packets belonging to an
established connection. The problem may not be sendmail at all, but a
coms issue. In fact, sendmail seems to be saying just that!

Thanks!

--
/"\
\ / ASCII Ribbon Campaign - Motor Vessel Tamara B
X against HTML email & vCards - http://www.tamara-b.org
/ \ Tania Our Cat http://www.tamara-b.org/t1.jpg
.. . http://www.tamara-b.org/t2.jpg

Report this message