Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

am 22.09.2006 19:57:27 von p.sinner

During the last few weeks I heard a couple of times from the (freeware) firewall Comodo
downloadable at www.comodo.com

At a first glance this fw looks good from the GUI and it passes all leak test successfully.

Does someone know some dis-advantages of Comodo in comparison to other firewalls
e.g.like ZoneAlarm ?

Pete

Re: Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

am 23.09.2006 06:46:58 von Factor 13

"pete sinner" wrote:
> During the last few weeks I heard a couple of times from the (freeware)
> firewall Comodo
> downloadable at www.comodo.com
>
> At a first glance this fw looks good from the GUI and it passes all leak
> test successfully.
>
> Does someone know some dis-advantages of Comodo in comparison to other
> firewalls
> e.g.like ZoneAlarm ?
>
> Pete

No known problems so far, looks a good alternative to ZoneAlarm.

Re: Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

am 23.09.2006 09:27:38 von Volker Birk

In comp.security.firewalls pete sinner wrote:
> At a first glance this fw looks good from the GUI and it passes all leak test successfully.

It does not. Please read the threads here about Commodo.

Yours,
VB.
--
Viel schlimmer als die Implementation von PHP ist jedoch das Design.

Rudolf Polzer in de.comp.security.misc

Re: Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

am 23.09.2006 18:06:14 von Notan

Volker Birk wrote:
>
> In comp.security.firewalls pete sinner wrote:
> > At a first glance this fw looks good from the GUI and it passes all leak test successfully.
>
> It does not. Please read the threads here about Commodo.

The majority (all?) of the negative comments are from the
personal-firewalls-don't work crowd. Take those comments
for what they're worth.

It has its limitations, as I'm sure all software firewalls do.

Personally, from an operational standpoint, it appears to have
a much smaller footprint the the ever-growing ZoneAlarm..

Notan

Re: Is Comodo firewall really good in comparison to other firewalls (e.g. ZoneAlarm)?

am 23.09.2006 20:01:34 von Kerodo

In article <45155B76.7D5251A2@ddress.thatcanbespammed>,
notan@ddress.thatcanbespammed says...
> Volker Birk wrote:
> >
> > In comp.security.firewalls pete sinner wrote:
> > > At a first glance this fw looks good from the GUI and it passes all leak test successfully.
> >
> > It does not. Please read the threads here about Commodo.
>
> The majority (all?) of the negative comments are from the
> personal-firewalls-don't work crowd. Take those comments
> for what they're worth.
>
> It has its limitations, as I'm sure all software firewalls do.
>
> Personally, from an operational standpoint, it appears to have
> a much smaller footprint the the ever-growing ZoneAlarm..
>
> Notan
>

It does seem to have a following and is gaining converts from the ZA
crowd. To me it still seems a little buggy and is probably overly
complex. Also, there is no way to edit a rule on the fly, which really
puts me off. But it is probably a pretty decent leak test stopper if
that's what you seek.

--
Kerodo